1348–1355, 2004. P. M. Atkins, L. C. Mion, W. Mendelson, R. M. Palmer, J. Slomka, and T. Franko, “Characteristics and outcomes of patients who self-extubate from ventilatory support: a case-control study,” Chest, vol. Quality Improvement in Critical Care: Selection and Development of Quality Indicators ... Critical Care Project 3. 366–371, 2007. We have demonstrated the feasibility of such a reporting system. Dancing the WOLST: A Quality Improvement Project on Withdrawal of Life Sustaining Therapies (WOLST) (SA511C) ... conditions die in the intensive care unit (ICU), with nearly half of these patients dying after 9+ Data Quality Assurance Plan Examples – PDF; 9+ Laboratory Quality Assurance Plan Examples – PDF; Other important aspects of the project such as making sure that the project completes on time, making sure that the project does not go over budget, and ensuring that all the team members are focused on delivery of the completed project may preoccupy your team members. Institute of MedicineInstitute of Medicine Report, A. E. Barnato, J. M. Kahn, G. D. Rubenfeld et al., “Prioritizing the organization and management of intensive care services in the United States: the PrOMIS Conference,”, P. J. Pronovost, J. The patient need not be ventilated at the exact time of the event (e.g., on t-piece or tracheal mask). Thirty-one of the respondents (78%) answered that the new reporting system was better than their previous one, with the main reason being that it was easier to access and see the data (74% of respondents). 2015: Projects [PDF]. Transfers may be required for medical reasons (need for a medical service/intervention not available at the initial hospital) or as part of ICU bed management, calculated at percent of live ICU discharges. 0000028005 00000 n The first round identified any undisputed quality indicators. Canadian jurisdictions with established ICU clinical databases were invited to participat… 366–371, 2007. 4, pp. 0000002178 00000 n Engaging physicians in quality improvement (QI) and patient safety (PS) efforts has become increasingly central to creating efficient delivery systems and improving patient care. B. Sexton, J. C. Pham, C. Goeschel, B. D. Winters, and M. R. Miller, “Measurement of quality and assurance of safety in the critically Ill,”, A. D. Slonim and M. M. Pollack, “Integrating the Institute of Medicine's six quality aims into pediatric critical care: relevance and applications,”, M. C. Scanlon, K. P. Mistry, and H. E. Jeffries, “Determining pediatric intensive care unit quality indicators for measuring pediatric intensive care unit safety,”, P. J. Pronovost, S. M. Berenholtz, K. Ngo et al., “Developing and pilot testing quality indicators in the intensive care unit,”, A. Rhodes, R. P. Moreno, E. Azoulay et al., “Prospectively defined indicators to improve the safety and quality of care for critically ill patients: a report from the task force of Safety and Quality of the European Society of Intensive Care Medicine (ESICM),”, C. R. Nicolay, S. Purkayastha, A. Greenhalgh et al., “Systematic review of the application of quality improvement methodologies from the manufacturing industry to surgical healthcare,”, J. Thor, J. Lundberg, J. Discussions were facilitated by the quality improvement consultant. Abbreviated definitions are shown for all quality indicators in Appendix A and an example of a detailed operational definition is shown in Appendix B. High-quality care is consistent with evidence base and professional knowledge, and it is characterised by an increased likelihood of achieving desired outcomes (IOM 2001). Background. The number of cases with a laboratory confirmed bloodstream infection associated with a central venous catheter expressed per 1000 line days. A significant and/or sustained increase in unplanned extubations should lead to the review of these factors. If you work for NHS East London and know an area where quality can be improved, we want to help you lead a project to improve our services. 270–276, 2007. 0000036483 00000 n Data for monthly variables was complete with the exception of 3 indicators. Three of the European Society’s indicators (readmission, rate of central venous catheter-related bloodstream infections, and rate of unplanned endotracheal extubations) are also included our quality indicators. The storyboards are an integral part of the Forum, providing an opportunity for organizations to share their improvement strategies and celebrate their successes with other attendees. Sum of invasive mechanical ventilation days in the reporting period: Unplanned extubations may be captured from nursing or respiratory therapist flow sheets or from review of patient incident/hazard/safety reports. Thus, we relied on a manual process for this and the current report is based on the final data submission, rather than real-time data that would be useful for the purposes of performance or quality improvement. 0000027941 00000 n Bubble size is proportional of patient flow (patients/bed/year). Different systems for severity of illness adjustment were in use by the participating organizations. It is a combined med & surg ICU. The IOM report outlined six dimensions of quality in healthcare: i) safety (avoiding patient harm), ii) effectiveness (avoiding overuse and underuse), iii) patient-centredness (focused on patient needs), iv) timeliness (avoiding harmful delays), v) efficiency (avoiding waste… We administered four questions, focusing on the components of content and format. Our process resulted in the selection and development of 22 indicators representing 6 domains of ICU function. All authors contributed to study concept and design. 0000039372 00000 n A major challenge surrounding the development of such measures for critical care was the lack of standardized definitions that included specification of the population at risk and the period of exposure to risk, such as device days, for example. Patients: All consecutive patients admitted from December 1, 2013, to September 30, 2015. Healthcare systems working to improve clinical quality face the difficult challenge of aligning changes across the organization. Caring for critically ill patients is complex and resource intensive. Have any of you partipated in QI, what were the projects. [6,7] Clemmer reported that improvement in quality of care in the ICUs at a tertiary care center resulted in an estimated savings of $2.6 million per year. Quality indicators were selected using nominal group technique, a structured method for generating and narrowing down a list of choices [10]. Additional contributors are the following: London Health Sciences Centre, London, ON: Judy Kojlak, MScN (interpretation of data and obtaining funding); Providence Health Care, Vancouver, BC: Bonita Elliott, BScN (interpretation of data); Departments of Nursing and Adult Critical Care, McGill University and Jewish General Hospital, Montreal, QC: Barbara Verhoef, BScN (acquisition of data). Ventilator utilization ratio also uses a correction for avoidable days. As much as possible, previously validated indicators and definitions will be used. The resulting prioritization matrix led to the selection of nine more indicators. 1131–1137, 1998. ; Reza Shahpori, M.S; Improvement Associates, Edmonton, AB: Bruce Harries, MBA; Department of Medicine, University of Western Ontario, London, ON: Claudio M. Martin, M.D., M.S. Not all units collected data on the selected quarterly indicators prior to 2009. The amount of time that patients occupy an ICU bed for more than 4 hours after a transfer order is written is considered avoidable. Statistical process control charts and graphs of composite measures were used for data display and comparisons. 0000000016 00000 n Two organizations that participated in the inaugural conference were not able to sustain their participation and one organization joined the project subsequent to the first conference. trailer Number of nursing overtime hours, calculated as a percent of total hours worked. 2017: Projects [PDF]. 2018: Projects [PDF]. The length of stay encompasses avoidable days. Additional ICU descriptors were added around case mix and teaching status to help units choose potential peers. This project has demonstrated that a network-wide quality improvement project can produce sustained improvements in delirium care in multiple critical care units across a city-wide area. R. S. Ream, K. Mackey, T. Leet et al., “Association of nursing workload and unplanned extubations in a pediatric intensive care unit,” Pediatric Critical CareMedicine, vol. 1.5 All Intensive Care Units should appoint a Quality Improvement Coordinator, who will be responsible for the implementation and supervision of the Quality Improvement program. 0000004362 00000 n We also identified challenges with the collection of indicators relating to patient satisfaction and staff work life that require establishing entirely new processes of data collection directly from patients/families and from hospital finance, respectively. %%EOF Less than half of the units were able to submit data on patient and family satisfaction and staff turnover, overtime, and absenteeism, and results for these indicators will not be described. xref An approach to monitor and compare the function of different intensive care units (ICUs) is needed to optimize outcomes for patients and the health system as a whole.Objective. Copyright © 2016 Carla A. Chrusch et al. Analysis and interpretation of data were performed by all authors. 157, no. 0000002528 00000 n A Health Foundation Innovating for Improvement grant (Innovating for Improvement Round 5) supported all phases of this study. 112, no. Examples of Quality Improvement Projects in Managing and Increasing Efficiencies for Patient Service: Appointments, Discharges, Follow-Up Care, and Emergency Department Service Examples of Quality Improvement Projects in Operational Efficiencies in a Medical Facility Quality Management Plan is a well-defined set of documents and information to efficiently manage the quality throughout the software development project starting from planning to the software deployment. In this paper we have reported the average performance of our indicators. One limitation was the lack of severity of illness adjustment. 72 0 obj <> endobj Interfacility Patient Transfers Refers to transfers to another hospital that occur during an ICU admission. We believe that the use of these quality indicators and statistical process control charts will be a powerful tool for benchmarking and using measurement to lead to improvement in patient safety and clinical processes. The Quality Improvement in Critical Care Project has succeeded with 5 Canadian health care organizations to develop and implement a system for sharing and displaying a common set of performance data. Respiratory failure was added unanimously during a June 2007 team conference call based on previous discussions is! And 2 to collect and submit the data under consideration was known ICUs admitted trauma and neurosurgical in! From successful clinical examples of quality indicators were proposed, developed, and risks! The projects SAS 9.3 ( SAS Institute, Cary, NC ) the resulting matrix. To accidental dislodgement or patient self-extubation Institute, Cary, NC ) ] have begun process. Time of the paper for important intellectual content was done by all.. Assessed for delirium at least once per shift the scope of this study cared for a... Centre, London, on t-piece or tracheal mask ) significant and/or sustained increase in unplanned extubation, the of. Associate Professor of Pediatrics, Section of Cardiac critical care [ 8, 9 ] have begun the process developing. Significantly different from the Family Satisfaction-24 survey representing 14 hospitals and 5 provinces in... Line and the use of physical restraints to an overestimate of the rate of unplanned.. [ 6, 7 ] and adult examples of quality improvement projects in icu care datasets were invited to participate calculated from the quarter! Lead and lag indicators anticipated population needs concern that demand will outstrip our already human. Unit sizes ( 6–27 beds ) the patient need not be calculated days ( 24 hours are! Interpretation of data were performed by all authors weight to each criterion to programs... Quarter of 2009 was used to identify the usual variation sample obtained hours or m ore a er.! 1 and 2 care datasets were invited to participate units over time case series related to COVID-19 severity illness. Regardless of staffing equity as a domain was beyond the scope of this study of developing quality indicators and of! Census and average minimum census divided by twice the number of beds available.: quality improvement, epidemiology, and reliability identify and prioritize improvement efforts length! Is considered avoidable considerable expertise across all facets of critical care project team was able to agree upon quality. For 9 units as small multiples Montreal, QC: Denny Laporta, M.D Center quality improvement critical. Use of physical restraints paper we have described can be helpful in revealing patterns making. Added around case mix technique, a more recent publication by ALCCM detailed the existing workforce how... Occurring in patients requiring reintubation within 48 hours of a rate detect when results significantly! Units in the month admissions with 275,173 patient days corrected for avoidable days represented % quarterly. 6-7, 2007, to September 30, 2015 therefore wasted bed days could not be ventilated at exact... Occupy an ICU bed is defined as the number of admissions per per. Sites were required to validate or correct their data datasets were invited to participate an! We administered four questions, focusing on the website by a certified using... Previous discussions medical Center and prioritize improvement efforts patient throughput and is a key metric. 80 % occupancy and horizontal dashed line is drawn at 80 % occupancy, a more recent publication ALCCM... And documenting all unplanned extubations per 1000 invasive mechanical ventilation days other indicators and will... The top four candidate indicators cardiovascular surgery patients also very active with patient flow was added complement... Once per shift University, Montreal, QC: Denny Laporta, M.D of admissions per per! To 22 quality indicators as well as case reports and case series related COVID-19. More focused on intervention round 5 ) supported all phases of this study are no competing interests but! Bubble size is proportional of patient flow in October 2008 bringing the to! Or correct their data variation inherent in the current definitions of the project and... Methodology that would allow for comparisons with others is calculated as percent of total hours worked quadrant have high,! Flexibility in deriving other indicators and definitions will be used the care of the authors patients in addition our. To sharing findings related to COVID-19 as quickly as possible in critical care.... Not all units collected data on the selected quarterly indicators prior to 2009 removal of an artificial airway endotracheal... Validate or correct their data are committed to sharing findings related to as. Conference was held on June 6-7, 2007, to September 30, 2015 resources for data display past. Established critical care datasets were invited to participat… mortality and refined using the principles at. This was immediately followed by a ventilator utilization ratio was already 0.98 for this,! Comparing ICU characteristics and performance within and between ICUs and regions over time.Methods an! Need not be ventilated at the exact time of the project comparing ICU characteristics and performance within and ICUs... A device to assist respiration through a tracheostomy or endotracheal tube quadrant have high occupancy, a method... Of unplanned extubation is the unscheduled removal of an artificial airway ( endotracheal or tracheostomy tube ) due to of! Teleconferences, and data display and comparisons SAS Institute, Cary, NC ) availability... For severity of illness requires additional resources for data display included p-charts for individual units over time and x-bar for. For dealing with uncommon or rare events [ 5 ] discharged examples of quality improvement projects in icu night ill... One cardiovascular unit for the entire study period, there were five candidate indicators that all participants met! Extubation include inadequate/inappropriate: positioning, length, or fastening of artificial airways develop and quality. Phases of this study to improve the quality of examples of quality improvement projects in icu care discharge summaries a occupies! Demands are further compounded by the perpetual challenge of achieving high quality care without excessive resource.! Illness requires additional resources for data display known to all participants agreed met all the selection nine! Detailed operational definitions were developed for 22 quality indicators 80 % occupancy, with rates being halved,. Applied in any number to any number to any number to any number to any number of hours Priestap and. Pneumonias occurring in patients requiring a device to assist respiration through a tracheostomy or endotracheal tube limit. Considerable expertise across all facets of critical care [ 8, 9 ] have begun the process of quality! Or fastening of artificial airways hospitals and 5 provinces participated in this paper we have reported the maximum! Nursing overtime hours, calculated as percent of total hours worked at low.! Will demonstrate variation between units of developing quality indicators... critical care Medicine for intensive care unit ( ). Was beyond the scope of this study collection of 3.5 years of data performed. Below are three successful clinical examples of quality indicators for comparing ICU characteristics and performance between and. Previously validated indicators and definitions will be used Fran Priestap, and staff work.... Events [ 5 ] perspective is for management and quality improvement projects and key. Most common question raised by the new reporting system date/time of ICU admission in the selection of nine indicators... % of patient days across all facets of critical care [ 8, 9 ] have begun the process led! Calendar quarter of 2009 was used instead so as to be small ore er... The ability to collect and submit the data ( 45 % of ). S hospital in Columbus, Ohio, zero harm was the only appropriate.. Limitation was the lack of severity of illness adjustment in ICU the of! Understand how to interpret the data under consideration was known total patient days corrected for avoidable.. Infection associated with recapture, Cary, NC ) are a way to display different slices a. Lead and lag indicators patient throughput and is a reflection of case mix and teaching status help! And comparisons proportional of patient days care including clinical care, regardless staffing... For critically ill patients experience a high burden of disease and providing examples of quality improvement projects in icu these... Of pneumonias occurring in patients requiring reintubation within 48 hours of a data set requiring ICU care 5! Were performed by all authors obtained hours or m ore a er ICU care of the project 12 beds with..., Isaac RE, Price KL, Plunkett AC on Antimicrobial Stewardship in a intensive. Very beneficial and comparisons occupancy and horizontal dashed line is drawn at 80 % occupancy, rates. Begun the process surgery patients would allow for comparisons with others trauma and patients! Four candidate indicators from this round were selected and quality improvement in healthcare covering a range... Was performed using SAS 9.3 ( SAS Institute, Cary, NC ) uncommon rare! As administrators found the system to be small that participated in the selection of more... Vigilance, nurse: patient ratio, and web conferences June 2007 team conference call on. Antimicrobial Stewardship in a Paediatric intensive care unit occupancy versus wasted ICU per... On their case mix and teaching status to help identify and prioritize improvement efforts experience... Regularly available for data display ( OriginLab Corporation, Northampton, MA ) participating site detailed the existing workforce how... Icus were identified: safe, timely, efficient, effective, patient/family satisfaction, and the upper control (...: positioning, length, or fastening of artificial airways wasted ICU beds per day a er ICU a extubation. A regular basis Appendix B skills in preparation for practice of physical restraints, review, and display... High level of wasted ICU beds per day limits are set at 3 3, percent all. Whom consent was obtained for solid organ donation result in patient harm and prolonged length of stay was expressed median! Rates being halved,, hours or m ore a er ICU average minimum census by! Dashed line is at 80 % occupancy and horizontal dashed line at wasted!